For any true devotee of metalcore, the name Of Mice & Men resonates with a powerful blend of intense emotion and relentless aggression. Hailing from Costa Mesa, California, this American band has continually evolved its sound, transitioning from raw post-hardcore to a more melodic and anthemic form of alternative metal, all while maintaining their signature blend of crushing riffs and deeply personal lyrics. Their journey, marked by perseverance through adversity, has solidified their place as a significant and enduring force in the heavy music scene.
Of Mice & Men was founded in 2009 by former Attack Attack! vocalist Austin Carlile and bassist Jaxin Hall. The band’s intriguing name is, in fact, a direct reference to John Steinbeck’s classic novella of the same title, reportedly chosen to reflect themes of “the best-laid plans of mice and men often going awry” in their own lives, a poignant detail for any literature and music enthusiast. Their self-titled debut album, released in 2010, quickly gained traction, establishing their presence within the burgeoning metalcore genre with tracks like ‘Second & Sebring’ becoming fan favourites.
The band experienced several significant lineup changes in their early years, a common occurrence in the dynamic metalcore scene. Austin Carlile’s health issues (related to Marfan Syndrome, a connective tissue disorder) led to his initial departure and a brief period with Jerry Roush on vocals. However, Carlile returned, and the band continued to build momentum, particularly with their 2014 album Restoring Force, which saw them embracing a more accessible yet still heavy sound, charting highly and expanding their fanbase.
A pivotal moment in Of Mice & Men’s history came with Austin Carlile’s permanent departure in 2016 due to his ongoing health struggles. In a bold and ultimately successful move, bassist and clean vocalist Aaron Pauley stepped up to take over lead vocal duties. This transition marked a new era for the band, showcasing Pauley’s impressive versatility, from powerful clean vocals to guttural screams, leading to a refined sound that maintained their signature heaviness while allowing for greater melodic exploration. Albums like Defy (2018) and Earthandsky (2019) demonstrated this successful evolution.
An interesting fact about their recent creative process is their highly self-sufficient approach. For their upcoming album, frontman Aaron Pauley has taken an all-encompassing role, handling writing, producing, mixing, and mastering, aiming for a deeply personal and authentic sound. This level of in-house control highlights their commitment to their artistic vision. The band is comprised of Aaron Pauley (lead vocals, bass), Phil Manansala (lead guitar), Alan Ashby (rhythm guitar), and Valentino Arteaga (drums), a tight-knit unit that continues to push boundaries.